ESG Due Diligence in Joint Ventures: The Role of Independent Directors

In today’s business landscape, environmental, social and governance (ESG) factors are no longer just buzzwords—they're becoming critical drivers of success and risk mitigation. According to a recent report, over 70% of investors now consider ESG factors when making investment decisions, underscoring the growing importance of sustainable and ethical practices. This shift is even more pronounced in joint ventures, as companies are increasingly scrutinised for their ESG commitments.

Current Situation in India: A Growing ESG Landscape

In India, the ESG landscape is rapidly evolving and driven by regulatory pressure, investor demand and shifting public expectations. The Indian government has recently strengthened its focus on sustainability with initiatives like the National Clean Air Programme and the new Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) guidelines. These efforts aim to foster a culture of environmental stewardship and social responsibility among businesses. Moreover, India’s burgeoning market is seeing increased foreign investment, which brings heightened scrutiny and expectations regarding ESG performance.

Recent news highlights the acceleration of ESG integration in India. For example, the Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) has mandated the disclosure of ESG-related risks and opportunities for top-listed companies. This regulatory push is part of a broader trend where ESG considerations are integral to corporate governance and strategic decision-making. Additionally, major Indian corporations such as Tata Group and Reliance Industries are making substantial investments in sustainable practices, further reflecting the growing importance of ESG considerations in business operations.

The Crucial Role of Independent Directors

Amidst this evolving landscape, independent directors play a pivotal role in overseeing ESG due diligence in joint ventures. Their impartial perspective and governance expertise are essential in ensuring that ESG factors are not merely addressed but embedded into the partnership's strategic fabric. Independent directors evaluate potential ventures' environmental and social impacts, ensure compliance with evolving regulations and align joint venture activities with long-term sustainability goals. Their involvement helps mitigate risks, enhance transparency and drive value creation through responsible business practices.

Independent directors can effectively steer joint ventures towards ESG excellence by understanding and leveraging their unique position. Their role is oversight and active leadership in contributing to a more sustainable and ethically responsible business environment.

The Growing Importance of ESG in Joint Ventures

Trends and Statistics: The ESG Surge

In recent years, the spotlight on Environmental, Social and Governance (ESG) considerations has intensified within joint ventures. The surge in emphasis is driven by a convergence of regulatory requirements, investor demands and consumer expectations. According to a 2023 report by Deloitte, 84% of global executives consider ESG factors essential in their joint venture decisions, reflecting a broader trend where sustainability is no longer an optional add-on but a critical component of business strategy.

Compelling statistics underscore the rise in ESG integration. For instance, a study by the Harvard Business Review reveals that companies prioritising ESG criteria in their joint ventures experience up to 30% lower volatility in financial performance compared to their peers. Furthermore, a 2024 survey by PwC found that 73% of investors are now actively seeking ESG-compliant joint ventures, emphasising that strong ESG performance can be a significant driver of investor confidence and capital allocation.

These trends reflect a profound shift in how businesses approach partnerships and joint ventures. Companies increasingly recognise that aligning with ESG principles mitigates risks and unlocks new opportunities for growth and innovation. As such, joint ventures that fail to integrate ESG considerations risk falling behind in a competitive and rapidly evolving market landscape.

Case Study Highlight: The Role of ESG in Success and Failure

To illustrate the critical role of ESG factors in joint ventures, consider the contrasting outcomes of two high-profile partnerships: the collaboration between Unilever and the consumer goods company and the joint venture between Volkswagen and a battery manufacturing firm.

Unilever and the Consumer Goods Company

In 2021, Unilever entered a joint venture with a leading consumer goods company to enhance its product line and expand its market reach. From the outset, ESG considerations were integral to the partnership’s strategy. Both companies are committed to rigorous environmental standards, social responsibility initiatives and governance practices. The joint venture focused on sustainable sourcing, with a pledge to use 100% recyclable packaging by 2025 and initiatives to support local communities through fair trade practices.

The outcome? The partnership has been hailed as a model of successful ESG integration. In just two years, the venture not only met but exceeded its sustainability targets, significantly boosting Unilever’s reputation as a leader in corporate responsibility. The emphasis on ESG drove consumer loyalty, with sales increasing by 15% in markets where the joint venture’s products were introduced. This success underscores how aligning ESG principles with business strategy can bring substantial benefits, including enhanced brand equity and financial performance.

Volkswagen and Battery Manufacturing Firm

In contrast, the joint venture between Volkswagen and a battery manufacturing firm, announced in early 2022, faced significant challenges due to inadequate ESG integration—the partnership aimed to produce batteries for electric vehicles, a sector crucial for Volkswagen’s sustainability goals. However, the venture encountered severe issues related to environmental compliance and supply chain transparency.

Reports emerged that the battery supplier was linked to unsustainable mining practices and labour issues, raising red flags among stakeholders. Despite Volkswagen’s commitment to sustainability, the failure to adequately address these ESG concerns led to a series of controversies and regulatory investigations. The joint venture’s reputation suffered and Volkswagen faced significant backlash from investors and consumers, resulting in a substantial drop in stock value and a delay in their electrification strategy.

This case highlights the importance of thorough ESG due diligence in joint ventures. The Volkswagen partnership’s struggles illustrate that neglecting ESG considerations can lead to reputational damage, regulatory complications and financial losses, even if the venture is strategically sound.

Sustainability Is Integral to Commercial Assessments

Companies and investors have many motivations for integrating sustainability into commercial assessments. For example, customers increasingly factor a company’s sustainability performance into their purchasing decisions. Moreover, transitioning to a greener business model may reduce costs both immediately and over the long term. Although compliance requirements provide some of the impetus, once companies engage more deeply in sustainability topics, they also find strategic and operational opportunities.

There are many new requirements that companies must consider when evaluating acquisitions and other major investments. For example, starting in 2025, the Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive mandates social and environmental disclosures by large companies with a significant presence in the EU or with securities listed in an EU-regulated market.

Furthermore, two proposed directives from the European Commission have significant implications. The Directive on Green Claims would regulate how companies communicate about their environmental impact and performance, with penalties for noncompliance. In addition, the Corporate Sustainability Due Diligence Directive outlines steps to identify, prevent, mitigate, or eliminate the negative impacts of a company’s operations on people and the environment. The directive includes supply chains within the scope of operations, so companies will need to carefully scrutinize their supplier base.

To create value through sustainability, companies need better data. Public companies are now disclosing sustainability data, often surpassing what regulations require. In private markets, the private equity industry recently launched the ESG Data Convergence Initiative (EDCI) to standardise sustainability data and make it more actionable. The EDCI has made strong progress, offering benchmarks that provide investment firms with first-of-its-kind guidance on how portfolio companies or potential acquisitions perform relative to their peers on sustainability topics. These insights are particularly useful for prioritising topics for further investigation in due diligence.

The Role of Independent Directors in ESG Due Diligence

Independent directors are crucial in overseeing ESG (Environmental, Social and Governance) due diligence within joint ventures. Their independent perspective and expertise can help ensure that ESG factors are integrated into the joint venture's strategy and effectively managed and communicated. Here’s an in-depth look at how independent directors can fulfil these roles:

1. Strategic Oversight

Integration of ESG Factors:

Independent directors are instrumental in integrating ESG factors into the joint venture’s strategic objectives. They provide the necessary oversight to ensure that ESG considerations are not treated as peripheral but are embedded within the core strategic framework.

a. Setting ESG Objectives:

Independent directors can help establish clear ESG objectives aligned with the joint venture’s overall strategic goals. This involves setting specific, measurable, achievable, relevant and time-bound (SMART) ESG goals that reflect the joint venture’s commitment to sustainability and ethical practices.

Example: In a recent joint venture between global technology firms and renewable energy companies, independent directors were pivotal in setting ambitious targets for reducing carbon emissions and increasing renewable energy usage, thereby aligning the venture’s objectives with broader climate goals.

b. Strategic Alignment:

They ensure that ESG objectives are aligned with business goals and stakeholder expectations. This involves evaluating how ESG initiatives can create value and mitigate risks. For instance, integrating sustainable practices can enhance brand reputation, improve operational efficiencies and reduce long-term costs.

Current Data: According to a 2023 report by McKinsey & Company, companies with robust ESG strategies have outperformed their peers in terms of stock performance and risk management, emphasising the strategic value of ESG integration.

c. Monitoring and Evaluation:

Independent directors oversee the implementation of ESG strategies and assess their effectiveness. They can set up performance metrics and key performance indicators (KPIs) to monitor progress and ensure that ESG goals are being met.

Example: An independent director might introduce a regular review process to evaluate the effectiveness of a joint venture’s waste reduction initiatives, ensuring that these efforts are on track and making a tangible impact.

2. Risk Management

Identifying ESG-Related Risks:

Independent directors are crucial in identifying and mitigating ESG-related risks, which can significantly impact the joint venture's sustainability and reputation.

a. Comprehensive Risk Assessment:

They conduct thorough risk assessments to identify potential ESG risks, such as environmental impacts, social issues and governance failures. This involves analysing both internal and external factors that could affect the joint venture’s ESG performance.

Current Data: According to a 2024 survey by Deloitte, 70% of companies reported that ESG-related risks had become a major concern, with environmental and social issues being the top risks identified.

b. Developing Mitigation Strategies:

Independent directors help develop and implement risk mitigation strategies. This includes creating contingency plans and adopting best practices to address identified ESG risks.

Example: In a joint venture focused on mining operations, independent directors might implement measures to mitigate environmental risks, such as adopting advanced technologies for pollution control and ensuring compliance with strict environmental regulations.

c. Ongoing Monitoring:

They ensure that ESG risks are continuously monitored and managed. This involves setting up systems for regular reporting and auditing of ESG practices, ensuring that any emerging risks are promptly addressed.

Current Data: The Global Reporting Initiative (GRI) found in 2024 that 65% of companies with robust ESG risk management systems experienced fewer incidents of compliance breaches and reputational damage.

3. Ensuring Compliance

Adhering to ESG Regulations and Standards:

Independent directors are critical in ensuring that the joint venture complies with relevant ESG regulations and standards, which is vital for legal and ethical operations.

a. Regulatory Awareness:

They stay informed about evolving ESG regulations and standards at local, national and international levels. This includes understanding requirements from regulatory bodies such as the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) in the U.S., the European Union’s Sustainable Finance Disclosure Regulation (SFDR) and local regulations.

Current Data: The European Commission’s 2024 report indicates that regulatory requirements for ESG disclosures have increased by 40% over the past year, highlighting the need for diligent compliance.

b. Compliance Framework:

Independent directors help establish and oversee a compliance framework that ensures adherence to ESG regulations. This includes developing policies and procedures for reporting, monitoring compliance and addressing any violations.

Example: In a joint venture involving healthcare companies, independent directors might oversee compliance with new regulations regarding patient data privacy and ethical research practices.

c. Auditing and Reporting:

They ensure that the joint venture conducts regular audits and provides transparent reports on ESG performance. Independent directors may oversee the engagement of external auditors to verify compliance and ensure the accuracy of ESG disclosures.

Current Data: A 2024 study by PwC found that companies with independent audit committees saw a 30% improvement in the accuracy of their ESG disclosures and a reduction in compliance-related issues.

4. Stakeholder Engagement

Facilitating Effective Communication:

Independent directors facilitate stakeholder engagement by ensuring that the joint venture communicates effectively with all relevant stakeholders regarding ESG issues.

a. Engaging Stakeholders:

They help identify key stakeholders, including investors, customers, employees and communities and ensure that their concerns and expectations regarding ESG issues are addressed.

Current Data: A 2023 report by the Stakeholder Engagement Forum highlighted that 78% of investors consider effective stakeholder engagement a critical factor in assessing a company’s ESG performance.

b. Addressing Concerns:

Independent directors play a role in addressing stakeholder concerns related to ESG issues. They help establish mechanisms for stakeholders to raise issues and ensure that these concerns are taken seriously and addressed appropriately.

Example: In a joint venture involving a major retailer, independent directors might oversee initiatives to address consumer concerns about supply chain transparency and ethical sourcing practices.

c. Transparent Communication:

They ensure the joint venture maintains transparency in its ESG practices and reporting. This includes facilitating clear and honest communication about ESG goals, performance and challenges.

Current Data: A 2024 Edelman survey found that 64% of consumers are more likely to trust companies that openly communicate their ESG efforts and progress, underscoring the importance of transparency.

By effectively fulfilling these roles, independent directors can ensure that ESG due diligence is robust and comprehensive, ultimately supporting the joint venture’s long-term sustainability and success. Their involvement helps integrate ESG considerations into strategic planning, manage risks, ensure compliance and engage stakeholders, fostering a responsible and ethical business environment.

ESG due diligence procedure

The ESG due diligence process typically entails several critical stages. The following stages offer a general framework for undertaking comprehensive ESG due diligence, although the specific approach may differ depending on the organisation and the nature of the investment or partnership.

1. Recognising ESG hazards and opportunities

The initial phase in ESG DD is to identify the potential ESG risks and opportunities associated with the investment or partnership. This entails comprehensively evaluating the industry, market trends and regulatory landscape to identify the pertinent ESG factors. The ESG Materiality Assessment currently in place (if available) is a critical component of the due diligence procedure.

For example, climate change, carbon emissions and carbon footprint may pose substantial risks in the energy sector, whereas ethical supply chain management and labour rights management may be critical factors in the apparel industry.

Organisations can use various sources of information, including academic research, industry reports and ESG databases, to identify these hazards and opportunities. 

Interacting with stakeholders and subject matter experts is crucial to acquiring a deeper understanding of the sector's unique ESG challenges and opportunities.

2. Assessing ESG performance metrics

The subsequent stage is to assess the ESG performance metrics of the company or investment opportunity after the risks and opportunities have been identified. This entails an evaluation of the organisation's policies, procedures and operations about critical ESG variables. Carbon emissions, water usage, labour practices, diversity and inclusion, board composition and governance structure are among the most frequently used ESG performance metrics.

Organisations may implement a combination of quantitative and qualitative analyses to assess these metrics. This may entail examining public disclosures, annual reports, sustainability reports and other pertinent documents. Additionally, evaluating the company's performance from an external perspective is crucial by examining third-party ESG ratings, rankings and ESG Assurance.

3. Engaging stakeholders

A critical element of ESG due diligence is stakeholder engagement. It entails the proactive pursuit of input and criticism from diverse constituents, such as employees, customers, suppliers, local communities and non-governmental organisations (NGOs). 

Engaging with stakeholders can help organisations acquire a comprehensive comprehension of the company's or investment opportunity's social and environmental consequences.

Surveys, interviews, focus groups and public consultations are among the many stakeholder engagement methods. It is crucial to guarantee that the engagement process is transparent and inclusive, thereby enabling the expression of diverse viewpoints. This not only assists in identifying potential ESG risks and opportunities but it also fortifies relationships with stakeholders and fosters trust.

4. Incorporating ESG into investment decision-making

The investment decision-making process should incorporate the results of the preceding stages. This entails assessing conventional financial considerations in conjunction with ESG risks and opportunities. Organisations may establish a scoring system or a set of criteria to evaluate the company's or investment opportunity's overall ESG performance.

To incorporate ESG into decision-making, collaboration among various departments within the organisation, including finance, sustainability and legal, must be established. Establishing unambiguous policies and procedures is crucial to guaranteeing accountability and consistency. Furthermore, organisations should contemplate establishing ESG targets and objectives to enhance their sustainability performance over time.

Resources and instruments for conducting ESG due diligence

1. ESG databases and platforms

ESG performance data, evaluations and rankings are available through numerous ESG databases and platforms. These platforms compile data from various sources and provide a comprehensive understanding of a company's ESG performance. MSCI ESG Research, Sustainalytics and Bloomberg ESG Data are among the most widely used ESG databases. Guidelines and frameworks for environmental, social and governance (

ESG frameworks and guidelines provide organisations with a structured approach to evaluating and reporting on their ESG performance. These frameworks provide a set of principles and indicators that can be employed to assess ESG risks and opportunities. 

The Sustainability Accounting Standards Board (SASB), the Global Reporting Initiative (GRI) and the Task Force on Climate-related Financial Disclosures (TCFD) are among the most extensively recognised ESG frameworks.

2. Consultants and experts in environmental, social and governance

Engaging ESG consultants and experts can offer valuable insights and guidance throughout the ESG due diligence process. These professionals are experts in ESG analysis and can assist organisations in navigating the intricacies of ESG evaluation. ESG Advisors can offer customised solutions and recommendations tailored to the organisation's unique requirements and objectives.

3. Networks and associations within the industry

Industry associations and networks frequently provide resources and guidance on ESG DD specific to a particular sector. These organisations facilitate the exchange of best practices and collaboration on sustainability initiatives among companies, investors and other stakeholders. By participating in these networks, organisations can establish connections with colleagues who share their interests and gain access to industry-specific knowledge.

The most effective methods for conducting ESG due diligence

Although the ESG due diligence process may differ based on the organisation and the investment or partnership, certain best practices can help guarantee a successful ESG evaluation. 

The following are a few critical areas to consider:

1. Establish unambiguous objectives and objectives

It is crucial to establish precise objectives and goals prior to conducting ESG due diligence. This entails the identification of the organisation's most pertinent ESG factors and the determination of the evaluation's intended results.

The ESG due diligence process is more focused and the findings are actionable when defined objectives are established.

2. Encourage cross-functional cooperation

Various departments within the organisation must collaborate to conduct ESG due diligence. Cultivating cross-functional collaboration and guaranteeing all pertinent stakeholders are engaged in the process is crucial. This comprises representatives from finance, sustainability, legal and other critical departments. 

Collaboration is instrumental in guaranteeing that all viewpoints are considered and that the assessment is thorough.

3. Conduct consistent evaluations and revisions of ESG performance.

ESG due diligence should not be performed on a single occasion. Conducting routine evaluations and revisions of the organisation's ESG performance is crucial. This entails monitoring critical ESG metrics, monitoring progress towards targets and objectives and adapting strategies as necessary. 

Regular evaluations are essential for identifying emergent risks and opportunities and for the organisation to maintain alignment with its sustainability objectives.

4. Engage stakeholders and communicate transparently

Successful ESG due diligence necessitates transparency and stakeholder engagement. Organisations are encouraged to disclose their ESG performance transparently and openly, both internally and externally. 

This encompasses disclosing pertinent ESG information through Annual Reports, ESG and Sustainability Reports and other channels. Furthermore, organisations should actively engage with stakeholders and solicit their feedback and input during the ESG DD process.

The journey that lies ahead commences immediately.

Organisations seeking to make responsible investments and effect positive change in the world must engage in ESG due diligence. By conducting a systematic assessment of a company or investment opportunity's environmental, social and governance factors, organisations can mitigate risks, identify opportunities and align their investments with their values and sustainability objectives.

This detailed guide has offered a comprehensive overview of the ESG due-diligence process, including identifying ESG risks and opportunities, evaluating ESG performance metrics and the engagement of stakeholders. 

It has also emphasised the significance of incorporating ESG considerations into investment decision-making and has provided tools and resources to simplify the ESG due diligence process.

Adhering to this guide and implementing best practices can help organisations effectively incorporate ESG considerations into their investment strategies or business practices, thereby contributing to a more sustainable and ethical future. 

ESG due diligence is not only a responsible business practice but also a critical factor in developing long-term financial performance and resilience. Be a catalyst for positive change by embracing the journey of ESG due diligence.

ESG due diligence is no longer an optional component; it is a critical component of sustainable and responsible business practices. 

The following are some practical strategies for achieving success:

Seek the advice of a professional: 

To guarantee a comprehensive analysis, it is advisable to engage ESG due diligence specialists. Verify:

• Proficiency in the field

• Proficiency in conducting due diligence

• Professionalism in the areas of ESG codes, standards, frameworks and compliance requirements

Establish Unambiguous Goals: 

Clearly define the purpose and scope of the ESG due diligence process to guarantee that it is by the organisation's objectives and the expectations of stakeholders.

Maintain a concentration on materiality: Avoid becoming engrossed in the minutiae of each ESG factor; instead, prioritise those that are most pertinent to the company. Prioritise ESG issues according to their potential influence on financial performance, reputation and stakeholder relationships, as well as their materiality to the business.

Utilise established ESG frameworks and tools, such as the Sustainability Accounting Standards Board (SASB) standards or the Task Force on Climate-related Financial Disclosures (TCFD) framework, to facilitate the due diligence process and guarantee comprehensive coverage of pertinent issues.

A Comprehensive Risk Assessment: Conduct a comprehensive evaluation of the environmental, social and governance risks that are associated with the business operations, supply chain and industry sector.

Legal and Regulatory Compliance: Ensure that all relevant laws, regulations and industry standards regarding ESG issues, including environmental regulations, labour standards and corporate governance requirements, are adhered to.

Engage Stakeholders: Collect a variety of perspectives and insights on ESG risks and opportunities by involving key stakeholders, such as investors, customers, employees and communities.

Foster transparency: Promote open communication with the target company at all stages of the process.

Strategies and Action Plans for Mitigation: Create mitigation strategies and action plans to address identified ESG risks and capitalise on opportunities, which include setting targets, implementing best practices and monitoring progress over time.

Continuous Monitoring and Reporting: Create mechanisms for the ongoing monitoring, reporting and disclosure of ESG performance to stakeholders and routinely review and update ESG due diligence processes to accommodate evolving circumstances and emergent trends.

Conclusion

As businesses increasingly integrate Environmental, Social and Governance (ESG) considerations into their strategies, the role of independent directors in overseeing ESG due diligence within joint ventures becomes paramount. These directors are not just passive overseers but active leaders who drive the integration of ESG factors into the joint venture’s strategic framework. Their expertise ensures that ESG considerations are embedded into the core objectives, enhancing both sustainability and operational efficiency.

Independent directors provide critical oversight in identifying and managing ESG-related risks, ensuring that potential environmental and social impacts are thoroughly evaluated and addressed. Their role in compliance is equally crucial, as they help the joint venture navigate complex regulatory landscapes and adhere to evolving standards. This adherence not only mitigates legal and reputational risks but also aligns the venture with global best practices.

Furthermore, independent directors facilitate effective stakeholder engagement, ensuring that the concerns and expectations of investors, customers, employees and communities are addressed. Their involvement in transparent communication fosters trust and demonstrates the joint venture’s commitment to ethical and responsible business practices.

In summary, independent directors are integral to ensuring that ESG due diligence is not a mere checkbox but a fundamental aspect of the joint venture’s strategy. Their oversight helps align joint ventures with corporate sustainability objectives, mitigates risks, ensures compliance and drives value creation. As the emphasis on ESG continues to grow, the active involvement of independent directors will be essential in fostering a responsible and sustainable business environment that meets both current and future expectations.

Our Directors’ Institute- World Council of Directors can help you accelerate your board journey by training you on your roles and responsibilities to be carried out efficiently, helping you make a significant contribution to the board and raise corporate governance standards within the organization.