.png)
In recent years, the global economy has witnessed a significant shift towards sustainability, with the circular economy emerging as a pivotal concept in driving environmental and economic resilience. The circular economy paradigm emphasises the need for businesses to move away from the traditional linear model of “take, make, dispose” and instead embrace practices that prioritise resource efficiency, waste reduction and sustainable growth. This transformation is not merely an ethical imperative. Still, it is increasingly a strategic necessity as evidence mounts that circular economy practices can deliver substantial financial benefits, with businesses embracing circular principles potentially achieving up to 50% in material cost savings and environmental benefits.
India, a rapidly growing economy with a burgeoning population and increasing industrial activity is at the forefront of adopting circular economy principles. Recent trends highlight a robust governmental and corporate push towards sustainability. For instance, the Indian government has set ambitious targets under the National Resource Efficiency Policy and the Swachh Bharat Mission, focusing on reducing waste and improving resource efficiency. The Indian circular economy market is projected to reach $64 billion by 2025, demonstrating the scale of opportunity in this transition.
Independent directors, whose role traditionally revolves around governance and oversight, are increasingly recognised as crucial enablers of circular economy initiatives. Their unique position within corporate boards allows them to champion sustainability goals and drive systemic change. Independent directors bring an external perspective and expertise that can challenge conventional practices, promote innovative strategies and ensure accountability in adopting circular economy practices.
Recent data underscores the growing importance of circular economy adoption. A report by the Ellen MacArthur Foundation highlights that businesses embracing circular principles could achieve up to 50% in material cost savings and significantly lower their carbon footprint. In India, adopting circular economy practices is also gaining momentum, with companies like Mahindra & Mahindra and ITC Limited spearheading initiatives that reflect a commitment to resource efficiency and waste reduction. The government’s focus on circular economy is evident in its policy framework, which aims to promote sustainable industrial practices and reduce environmental impact.
Independent directors can leverage these trends by guiding companies in integrating circular economy principles into their core strategies. Their role extends beyond mere compliance; they foster a culture of innovation, ensure rigorous environmental performance metrics, and align corporate objectives with broader sustainability goals. By advocating for circular practices, independent directors enhance their companies' competitive advantage and contribute to broader environmental and societal goals, motivating the audience with potential business benefits.
What is the circular economy?
Our current economic system is a "linear economy," based on the extraction of basic materials from the natural world, their transformation into products, and their subsequent disposal as refuse. Only 7.2 per cent of used materials are recycled back into our economies after their use. This has a substantial impact on the environment and exacerbates the climate, biodiversity, and pollution crises.
Conversely, the circular economy endeavours to reduce waste and encourage the sustainable utilisation of natural resources by implementing intelligent product design, extended use, recycling and other methods, and regenerating the environment.
The circular economy can be instrumental in addressing other intricate challenges, including biodiversity loss and climate change, in addition to pollution.
What are some examples of circular economy?
Waste management is the initial example that most individuals associate with the term "circular economy," but it encompasses a much broader range of concepts.
Circular economy strategies are ubiquitous. They can be implemented in a variety of industries, such as textiles, structures and construction and at different phases of a product's lifecycle, such as design, manufacturing, distribution and disposal.
In the textiles and fashion industry, some initiatives use regenerative agriculture to produce organic cotton and other natural fibres, as well as natural colourings and dyes. This ensures that the health of consumers and the environment is protected by producing higher-quality and safer garments. By manufacturing garments of superior quality, clothing can be repaired, thrifted, and recycled and have an extended lifespan.
Circular solutions in the construction and architecture sector may involve substituting carbon-intensive materials with regenerative alternatives, such as timber, repurposing existing materials in circulation, or reducing primordial materials.
Electronic products are refurbished in a circular economy and the standard is water-soluble, recyclable and genuinely biodegradable packaging. Animal waste is processed into biogas for cooking, heating, and lighting and is used as natural fertiliser.
What is the significance of circular economies for the environment?
The current consumption of Earth's natural resources is estimated to exceed the available supply. If current trends persist, three planets will be required by 2050.
Over the past two decades, global material consumption has increased by more than 65 per cent, culminating in 95.1 billion metric tonnes in 2019. It is estimated that 13% of the food intended for human sustenance was lost after harvesting. An additional 17% was squandered at the household, food service and retail levels by the same year. In 2019, the average quantity of electronic waste per person was 7.3 kilogrammes and most of it is not properly managed, which has a detrimental impact on our health and the environment..
These statistics underscore the necessity of altering our approach to the utilisation and preservation of our finite resources to ensure the survival and well-being of both individuals and the planet. Research indicates that to achieve secure consumption limits, global material extraction and consumption must decrease by one-third. The transition to a circular economy will significantly facilitate this.
In what ways can the circular economy be used to combat climate change?
The prevention of climate change necessitates the implementation of a circular economy.
Currently, material extraction and use account for 70% of global greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions. This implies that to reduce emissions substantially, it is necessary to examine "hot spots" of unsustainable consumption and production in high-impact sectors, including agriculture, structures and construction.
Research indicates that circular economy strategies can reduce global greenhouse gas emissions by 40% by 2050 by promoting the efficient and circular utilisation of materials in only four critical industrial materials: cement, steel, plastics and aluminium. Additionally, the implementation of circular approaches within the agricultural system can result in a reduction of up to 49% in global GHG emissions.
Nationally Determined Contributions (NDCs) are climate commitments countries adopt as part of the Paris Agreement. These pledges are intended to enhance resilience against natural disasters and extreme weather conditions and reduce greenhouse gas emissions. By incorporating circular economy strategies into these pledges, countries can expedite the transition to a low-carbon economy, safeguard the natural environment and generate green, respectable and dignified employment opportunities.
The International Labour Organisation (ILO) has estimated that implementing additional circular activities, including recycling, repair, rent and remanufacturing, would generate six million jobs worldwide by 2030.
Existing models that are effective? Which countries are at the forefront of the circular economy?
Indeed, there is excellent news! Numerous countries and territories have already implemented circular economy strategies to transition development and growth to cleaner, greener and more regenerative paths.
Kosovo, for instance, is promoting innovative solutions for SMEs and start-ups, such as creating a mobile application that can detect environmental contamination and malfeasance in urban areas.
Ghana is assisting entrepreneurs in building houses from recycled plastic debris to enhance urban refuse management.
In the interim, countries such as Jordan foster opportunities for women by transitioning to a circular economy. This transition enables women to acquire new skills, establish businesses, assume community leadership positions and secure employment.
A law has been implemented in the Philippines that mandates large manufacturers reduce their plastic packaging usage and assume responsibility for the expenses associated with plastic waste management.
Many countries, including Mexico, strive to establish a more robust connection between climate action plans and circular economy solutions. Mexico is creating and executing training programmes for subnational authorities to identify circular economy initiatives that will contribute to the roadmap for implementing the updated NDC.
No other country has been estimated to be more circular than the island nation of Vanuatu. The country's domestic consumption was estimated to be circular at 59% in 2021. The Netherlands and Austria were the next two countries, with 24.5% and 9.7%, respectively. In contrast, the percentage of global circularity has decreased from 8.6% in 2020 to 7.2% in 2023.
The Independent Director’s Unique Role
Independent directors, by their position, hold a strategic role that can significantly influence a company’s approach to sustainability. Here’s how they can champion circular economy initiatives:
1. Strategic Vision and Oversight
Independent directors can drive the adoption of circular economy principles by integrating them into the company’s strategic vision. Their oversight role allows them to challenge traditional practices and encourage the board to adopt sustainability as a core business strategy. By advocating for circular economy models, independent directors can ensure that sustainability is not just a peripheral concern but a central aspect of the company’s long-term strategy.
2. Promoting Innovation
Innovation is at the heart of the circular economy. Independent directors can foster an environment that supports innovative approaches to product design, resource management and waste reduction. By encouraging R&D investments in circular technologies and processes, they helps companies stay ahead of regulatory requirements and market demands. For instance, supporting the development of products designed for disassembly and recycling can significantly enhance resource efficiency.
3. Ensuring Accountability
Accountability is a critical aspect of governance and independent directors are well-positioned to ensure that sustainability commitments are translated into actionable results. They can implement robust monitoring and reporting systems to track the company’s progress towards circular economy goals. This includes setting clear sustainability metrics, conducting regular audits and ensuring transparency in environmental performance.
4. Aligning with Regulatory and Market Trends
With increasing regulatory pressures and market expectations around sustainability, independent directors play a crucial role in guiding companies through compliance and beyond. In India, regulations such as the National Resource Efficiency Policy and the Swachh Bharat Mission are pushing companies towards more sustainable practices. Independent directors can help navigate these regulations and leverage them to enhance the company’s competitive edge.
5. Building Stakeholder Relationships
Circular economy practices often require collaboration across the value chain. Independent directors can facilitate partnerships with suppliers, customers and other stakeholders to promote circular practices. This might include developing closed-loop supply chains, engaging in joint sustainability initiatives and advocating for industry-wide standards.
6. Cultivating a Culture of Sustainability
Independent directors can influence the corporate culture by embedding sustainability into the company’s core values and operations. This involves leading by example, promoting sustainability training and encouraging employees at all levels to embrace circular economy principles. By fostering a culture of sustainability, independent directors help ensure that circular economy practices are deeply integrated into the company’s DNA.
Case Studies and Success Stories
Several Indian companies are already setting benchmarks in circular economy practices. For instance, Mahindra & Mahindra has incorporated circular economy principles into its operations by focusing on resource efficiency and waste reduction in its manufacturing processes. ITC Limited has implemented extensive waste management and recycling programmes, demonstrating the potential for circular practices to deliver both environmental and economic benefits.
These examples highlight the impact that dedicated leadership can have on advancing circular economy practices. Independent directors at these companies have played a pivotal role in driving these initiatives, showcasing the potential for broader industry transformation.
Championing Circular Economy Initiatives
Championing circular economy initiatives involves actively promoting and guiding a company’s transition from traditional linear business models to more sustainable, circular practices. Independent directors, with their strategic oversight and impartial perspective, are uniquely positioned to spearhead these efforts. Here’s how they can effectively champion circular economy initiatives:
1. Integrating Circular Economy Principles into Corporate Strategy
Strategic Vision: Independent directors can advocate for embedding circular economy principles into the company’s long-term strategy. This involves rethinking business models to focus on resource efficiency, durability and waste minimization. For instance, they might push for strategies emphasising product life extension, repairability and recyclability.
Goal Setting: They can help set clear, measurable sustainability goals aligned with circular economy objectives. This includes defining targets for reducing waste, increasing recycling rates, or improving resource utilisation. By integrating these goals into the company’s strategic plan, independent directors ensure that sustainability is a core component of business operations.
2. Promoting Innovation and Continuous Improvement
Encouraging Research and Development: Independent directors can drive innovation by supporting R&D investments to develop new circular economy solutions. This might include funding projects focused on creating sustainable materials, designing products for end-of-life recycling, or optimising supply chains to reduce waste.
Adopting Best Practices: They can advocate for adopting best practices and technologies that support circular economy principles. For example, they can encourage the implementation of closed-loop systems, where waste products are recycled back into production, or adopt modular design principles to facilitate product repair and upgrades.
3. Ensuring Accountability and Transparency
Monitoring Progress: Independent directors are key in establishing robust monitoring and reporting systems to track progress towards circular economy goals. This involves setting up key performance indicators (KPIs) for resource efficiency, waste reduction and sustainability and ensuring regular reporting on these metrics.
Conducting Audits: They can oversee periodic audits to assess the effectiveness of circular economy initiatives and identify areas for improvement. This helps ensure that concrete results back the company’s sustainability claims and that any discrepancies are addressed promptly.
4. Aligning with Regulatory Requirements
Compliance: Independent directors must stay informed about relevant environmental regulations and industry standards related to circular economy practices. They can ensure that the company complies with these regulations and leverage regulatory incentives or support programmes to promote sustainability.
Strategic Alignment: By aligning company practices with emerging regulatory trends, such as extended producer responsibility or mandatory recycling targets, independent directors can help position the company as a leader in sustainability, potentially gaining a competitive advantage.
5. Building Partnerships and Collaborations
Engaging Stakeholders: Independent directors can facilitate partnerships with suppliers, customers and other stakeholders to advance circular economy initiatives. This might involve collaborating on joint projects, sharing best practices, or working together to develop new circular solutions.
Industry Collaboration: They can also support involvement in industry-wide sustainability initiatives and networks, which can drive collective action and foster innovation in circular economy practices. This helps the company stay at the forefront of industry trends and standards.
6. Cultivating a Culture of Sustainability
Embedding Values: Independent directors can influence the corporate culture by promoting sustainability as a core value. This includes encouraging leadership to model sustainable behaviour, integrating sustainability into corporate policies and ensuring that circular economy principles are reflected in the company’s mission and vision.
Employee Engagement: They can advocate for training and development programmes that educate employees about circular economy practices and their benefits. By fostering a culture of sustainability, independent directors help ensure that circular economy initiatives are embraced at all levels of the organisation.
Strategic Vision and Leadership
Championing circular economy initiatives starts with embedding these principles into the core of a company's strategic vision. Independent directors, with their unique vantage point and strategic influence, are pivotal in steering their organisations towards a more sustainable future. Here's a detailed look at how they can drive this transformation:
Integration into Corporate Strategy
1. Redefining the Business Model:
Independent directors can advocate for a fundamental shift in the company's business model to align with circular economy principles. This might involve moving from a traditional product ownership model to a service-based model. For example, instead of selling products outright, the company could offer products on a subscription basis, encouraging regular returns for recycling or refurbishment. This not only fosters a circular approach but also creates new revenue streams and strengthens customer loyalty.
2. Leveraging Data for Circular Insights:
A forward-thinking approach involves integrating data analytics into strategic planning. Independent directors can champion the use of advanced data analytics to track product life cycles, monitor resource usage and identify opportunities for circular improvements. By using predictive analytics, companies can better anticipate maintenance needs, optimize product design for longevity and enhance recycling processes. For instance, implementing IoT sensors in products can provide real-time data on usage patterns and end-of-life indicators, guiding more effective circular strategies.
3. Building a Circular Ecosystem:
Advocating for the creation of a circular ecosystem within the company's supply chain is another crucial strategy. Independent directors can push for partnerships with suppliers and customers to develop closed-loop systems where waste materials are continuously recycled back into production. This might include setting up take-back programmes, collaborating on joint recycling initiatives, or investing in technologies that support circular processes, such as chemical recycling or biodegradable materials.
Setting Long-Term Goals
1. Transformative Sustainability Targets:
Independent directors can drive the establishment of transformative sustainability goals that go beyond incremental improvements. Instead of just aiming for waste reduction, they can set ambitious targets like achieving zero waste in landfills or reaching 100% renewable energy usage. These targets should be specific, measurable and time-bound, pushing the company to innovate and invest in new technologies and processes.
2. Creating a Roadmap for Circular Transition:
To turn high-level goals into actionable plans, independent directors can develop a detailed roadmap for the company’s transition to a circular economy. This roadmap should outline key milestones, resource requirements and timelines for implementing circular practices. For example, the roadmap might include phases such as pilot projects for circular design, scaling up successful initiatives and integrating circular principles across all product lines and operations.
3. Engaging in Industry Leadership:
Independent directors can position their company as an industry leader in circular economy practices by setting benchmarks that others aspire to. This involves not only adopting advanced circular practices but also sharing insights and strategies with industry peers, participating in thought leadership forums and contributing to the development of circular economy standards and frameworks. By taking a proactive role in shaping industry practices, independent directors can enhance the company’s reputation and influence the broader market.
4. Embedding Circular Economy in Corporate Culture:
To ensure that circular economy principles are deeply ingrained in the company’s DNA, independent directors should focus on cultural transformation. This involves fostering an internal culture that values sustainability and circularity, aligning corporate values with these principles and incentivizing employees to contribute to circular goals. For instance, introducing performance metrics and rewards tied to circular economy achievements can motivate employees to engage actively in sustainability initiatives.
5. Stakeholder Collaboration for Circular Innovation:
Finally, independent directors can lead efforts to engage with external stakeholders—such as NGOs, government bodies and academic institutions—to drive circular innovation. Collaborating with these entities can provide valuable insights, resources and support for implementing cutting-edge circular economy practices. For example, partnering with universities on research projects can lead to breakthroughs in sustainable materials or processes, which can then be integrated into the company’s operations.
Promoting Innovation and Best Practices
Promoting innovation and best practices is central to advancing circular economy initiatives within a company. With their strategic oversight and external perspectives, independent directors are uniquely positioned to drive these efforts. They can foster a culture of innovation, encourage cutting-edge research and ensure the adoption of best practices that propel the company toward a more sustainable future. Here’s how independent directors can make a significant impact:
Encouraging R&D
1. Fostering an Innovation-Driven Culture:
Independent directors can spearhead the creation of an innovation-driven culture by championing initiatives that encourage creative problem-solving and experimentation. This involves setting up dedicated innovation labs or “circular economy incubators” within the company where teams can explore new materials, technologies and processes that align with circular economy principles. Independent directors can stimulate groundbreaking research and development by providing funding and resources for these initiatives.
2. Strategic Partnerships for R&D:
To amplify the impact of R&D efforts, independent directors can advocate for strategic partnerships with universities, research institutions and startups. Collaborations with academic institutions can lead to joint research projects that explore new sustainable materials or recycling technologies. For instance, partnering with a university on a project to develop biodegradable alternatives to plastic packaging can yield innovative solutions that drive circularity.
3. Incentivizing Circular Innovations:
Independent directors can implement incentive programmes that reward employees and teams for developing innovative circular economy solutions. This might include recognition awards, financial bonuses, or opportunities for career advancement based on successful innovations. By creating a competitive and supportive environment, independent directors can motivate staff to focus on creating and implementing circular solutions.
4. Leveraging Technology and Digital Tools:
Encouraging digital tools and technologies is another way independent directors can support R&D. For example, utilising advanced simulation software and digital twins can help design products with longer lifecycles and optimized recycling processes. Independent directors can advocate for investment in these technologies to enhance the company's R&D capabilities and drive circular innovations.
Adopting Best Practices
1. Benchmarking Against Industry Leaders:
Independent directors can drive the adoption of best practices by benchmarking the company’s circular economy initiatives against industry leaders and top performers. Examining how companies like Patagonia implement circular practices, such as repair and recycling programmes, can provide valuable insights and inspiration. By setting similar high standards, independent directors can push their company towards best-in-class practices.
2. Implementing Circular Design Principles:
One of the most impactful best practices is integrating circular design principles into product development. Independent directors can champion the adoption of modular design, which allows products to be easily disassembled and repaired. They can also advocate for using sustainable materials and designing products that are easier to recycle or repurpose. For instance, promoting easily recyclable materials in product packaging can significantly reduce waste and enhance circularity.
3. Developing Closed-Loop Supply Chains:
Another best practice is developing closed-loop supply chains that minimise waste and maximise resource recovery. Independent directors can lead efforts to establish take-back schemes where used products are returned, refurbished and resold or recycled. This might involve collaborating with suppliers and customers to create a seamless system for collecting and processing end-of-life products.
4. Adopting Circular Metrics and Reporting Standards:
Independent directors can advocate for adopting circular economy metrics and reporting standards to track and communicate progress. Implementing frameworks such as the Global Reporting Initiative (GRI) Standards for circular economy or the Ellen MacArthur Foundation’s Circularity Indicators can provide a clear and standardized way to measure and report on circular practices. This transparency can enhance credibility and demonstrate commitment to stakeholders.
5. Driving Policy and Advocacy:
Independent directors can also influence industry policies and standards through advocacy and policy-making. Participating in industry groups and forums focused on circular economy practices can help influence the development of best practices and regulatory standards. This involvement positions the company as a thought leader and contributes to the broader adoption of circular economy principles across the industry.
6. Cultivating Cross-Functional Collaboration:
Encouraging cross-functional collaboration within the company can lead to implementing best practices in the circular economy. Independent directors can advocate for forming cross-disciplinary teams that bring together design, engineering, supply chain and sustainability experts. These teams can work together to develop and implement circular economy solutions, ensuring that best practices are applied across all aspects of the business.
Conclusion
As sustainability becomes a defining factor in modern business, independent directors are uniquely positioned to drive the adoption of circular economy practices within their organisations. Their role encompasses several critical responsibilities that advance the transition towards more sustainable, resource-efficient business models. Independent directors can significantly influence how companies integrate circular economy principles into their core strategies, ensuring that they are an add-on and a central aspect of long-term planning.
One of the primary roles of independent directors is to advocate for incorporating circular economy principles into the company’s strategic vision. This involves helping redefine business models to focus on resource efficiency and waste reduction and setting ambitious long-term sustainability goals that guide the company’s direction. By doing so, independent directors ensure that sustainability is embedded in every aspect of the business, from product design to supply chain management.
The adoption of best practices is equally important. Independent directors are vital in promoting integrating circular design principles, such as modularity and recyclability, into product development. They also help develop closed-loop supply chains that minimise waste and maximise resource recovery. Adopting and standardising circular metrics and reporting frameworks further ensures transparency and accountability, providing clear measures of progress towards sustainability goals.
Another key responsibility is ensuring that progress is monitored and reported transparently. Independent directors oversee the implementation of robust systems for tracking performance against circular economy goals, conducting regular audits to verify effectiveness and address any discrepancies. This oversight helps maintain a clear focus on achieving sustainability targets and demonstrates the company’s commitment to circular practices.
In addition, aligning with regulatory requirements is essential. Independent directors need to stay abreast of environmental regulations and industry standards related to circular economy practices. By ensuring compliance and leveraging regulatory frameworks, they can drive their companies toward more sustainable practices and gain a competitive edge in the market.
Finally, cultivating a culture of sustainability within the organisation is crucial. Independent directors can influence corporate culture by embedding sustainability into the company’s values and everyday operations. By fostering an environment that values circularity and incentivises sustainable practices, they ensure these principles are integrated into the company’s DNA.
Our Directors’ Institute- World Council of Directors can help you accelerate your board journey by training you on your roles and responsibilities to be carried out efficiently, helping you make a significant contribution to the board and raise corporate governance standards within the organization.
Comments